John Morton's Tavern Menu (Update 2026)

John Morton's Tavern serves a menu packed with satisfying flavors. The highlight includes the iconic Philly cheesesteak, available in various styles. Opt for the classic steak served with crunchy tots or crispy fries, or try the chicken cheesesteak for a lighter twist. For those craving a crunch, the famous egg rolls, featuring buffalo chicken and cheese steak fillings, deliver excitement in every bite. They also impress with hearty carvery sandwiches, like the hot roast pork and roast beef, perfect for lunch.

Not to be overlooked, the tavern offers a selection of wings in different sizes, ideal for sharing (or not!).

Pair your meal with cold drinks or side options that elevate your dining experience, ensuring there is something for everyone. Prices average around $12.13, providing excellent value for generous portions.

Featured Dishes

Philly Cheese Steak & Tots or Fries with Tots Fries and Ketchup
Philly Cheese Steak & Tots or Fries with Tots Fries and Ketchup
Fried Pickle Egg Rolls 3
Fried Pickle Egg Rolls 3
Hot Oven Baked Turkey Sandwich and Choice of Side
Hot Oven Baked Turkey Sandwich and Choice of Side
Cheesesteak Fries
Cheesesteak Fries
Philly Steak
Philly Steak
Bloody Mary
Bloody Mary
The Homesteader Sandwich and Choice of Side
The Homesteader Sandwich and Choice of Side
Cheesesteak Sandwich
Cheesesteak Sandwich
Roast Beef Pork
Roast Beef Pork
Roast Pork Long Hots
Roast Pork Long Hots
Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls 3
Buffalo Chicken Egg Rolls 3
Standing Rib Roast
Standing Rib Roast
Pot Roast
Pot Roast
John Morton's Tavern Menu image 1
John Morton's Tavern Menu image 2
John Morton's Tavern Menu image 3
John Morton's Tavern Menu image 4
John Morton's Tavern

John Morton's Tavern Interior, Food, Ambiance

The interior of John Morton's Tavern welcomes guests with warm vibes and a cozy atmosphere. Wooden accents create a rustic charm, making it the ideal spot for a casual meal or gathering with friends. Standing out, the lively bar area presents a great selection of beers on tap, perfect for pairing with any dish from the menu.

The vibrant ambiance invites camaraderie, often filled with laughter and chatter from locals enjoying their meals. Friendly staff add to the experience, providing attentive service while customers enjoy their culinary delights. With comfortable seating and an enticing aroma of delicious food, it feels like a second home for many regulars in Prospect Park.

John Morton's Tavern

About John Morton's Tavern Food and Specialties

Roast beef sandwiches, cheesesteaks, and wings take center stage at John Morton's Tavern, where flavor meets quality. This Prospect Park gem has carved out a reputation for its mouthwatering cheesesteaks, made with tender, perfectly seasoned meat nestled in fresh rolls. Each bite satisfies, bringing more than just sustenance. The star of the show, of course, is the cheesesteak, often deemed a local favorite and an absolute must-try.

The wings, available in sizes perfect for any appetite, complement the menu perfectly. Whether dining solo or sharing with friends, the wing flavors cater to varied palates.

And don't overlook their innovative egg rolls; they're not your run-of-the-mill appetizer. With notable mentions for the buffalo chicken and cheese steak versions, these egg rolls have become a quirky crowd-pleaser, enticing customers to come back for more.

John Morton's Tavern

John Morton's Tavern demonstrates a steadfast commitment to quality and community. The tavern specializes in turning simple ingredients into outstanding dishes, such as their renowned cheesesteak and flavorful wings. Their vision involves becoming not just a restaurant but a community hub where everyone can feel at home. With a focus on freshness and flavor, the menu is crafted to offer something for everyone, while maintaining a local, friendly atmosphere. Patron loyalty is nurtured by providing consistency in taste and hospitality, ensuring that every visit feels personal.